Ellen von Unwerth photographed the now-iconic image from the Live Through This cover, depicting model Leilani Bishop with a bouquet and a prom queen’s tiara as mascara tears ran down her face.
“Since I never got to go to prom, I wanted to throw a little prom party with my fav ppl ,” Rodrigo, 18, wrote on Twitter, announcing the film with the image of herself serving heartbroken prom queen.
Love chimed in on the discourse in her Facebook comments, explaining that it was “rude” to recreate the image without her permission, but added that she’s not that bothered by it since it happens to her frequently.
Rodrigo responded to Love on Instagram, showing her love for the Celebrity Skin artist.
It’s not the first time Rodrigo has been accused of taking inspiration from other artists.
“I’m just constantly learning and growing at such a rapid rate,” Rodrigo recently told PEOPLE after debuting Sour.